by A Minnesota man is facing serious charges after allegedly driving drunk and abandoning his injured fiancée following a heated argument that ended with her jumping out of his moving vehicle.
Authorities say the man, Johnathan James Schafer, never called 911 and instead spent more than 40 minutes on the phone with his mother and a friend before police were alerted.
What Happened
On the night of May 15, 2025, 35-year-old Schafer allegedly drove around with his fiancée, 23-year-old Julia Marie Marthaler, after they visited a bar for dinner and drinks.
An argument ensued, during which Marthaler reportedly jumped out of the moving truck. Schafer did not call emergency services. Instead, he contacted his mother and a friend.
Both women ultimately called 911 themselves, relaying Schafer’s claim that Marthaler had leapt from his truck near a cemetery in Becker, Minnesota.
Key Details
- Schafer was reportedly intoxicated during the incident.
- Authorities found him in a dog park parking lot, still on the phone and smelling of alcohol.
- Blood was discovered on the truck door and Schafer’s hand. A shotgun was also located in the vehicle.
- Schafer led police to Marthaler’s location, where she was found critically injured with severe head trauma. She was pronounced dead at the scene.
- Schafer never contacted 911 during the 42-minute window before his mother and friend alerted authorities.
Reactions or Statements
According to the police affidavit, Schafer told investigators he “panicked” after checking on Marthaler and fled when he saw headlights approaching.
He admitted they had argued and she jumped from the vehicle as he drove on a rural road.
Investigators noted that Schafer did not appear to make any effort to provide medical assistance or call for help.
Investigation or What’s Next
Schafer is currently in custody at the Sherburne County Jail with no bond.
He has been charged with DUI and failure to remain at the scene of an incident involving a likely death.
Authorities are awaiting the results of a blood test to determine Schafer’s blood alcohol content at the time of the incident.
His next court appearance is scheduled for June 18, 2025.
Additional charges may be filed as the investigation progresses.
Schafer has a prior record, including probation for violating a domestic violence protection order earlier this year.
FAQs
Who was the victim?
Julia Marie Marthaler, 23, was Schafer’s fiancée. She died from severe head trauma after reportedly jumping from a moving vehicle.
Why didn’t Schafer call 911?
According to police, Schafer instead called his mother and a friend. He claimed he “panicked” and drove away after checking on Marthaler.
Was Schafer intoxicated during the incident?
Police suspect Schafer was under the influence of alcohol. Blood test results are pending.
What charges is Schafer facing?
He is charged with DUI and failure to remain at the scene where death was likely. He may face additional charges.
What happens next in the case?
Schafer remains jailed without bond and is due in court on June 18, 2025. Investigators are continuing to review evidence.
Summary / Final Takeaway
The tragic death of Julia Marthaler has raised questions about accountability, impaired driving, and delayed emergency response.
As Schafer awaits his next court hearing, the case continues to unfold, with potential for further charges pending toxicology results and investigative findings.
