by A Delaware County man has been sentenced to 30 years in prison for fatally stabbing his pregnant wife and assaulting their two young daughters.
The victim’s father believes the attack stemmed from the husband’s disappointment that the unborn child was not a boy.
What Happened
On September 4, 2024, Drew J. Garnier of Masonville, NY, brutally attacked his pregnant wife, Samantha Garnier, and their two children inside their home on Houck Road.
Authorities say the incident occurred during a domestic dispute. Samantha and her unborn daughter were killed, and the two children sustained serious injuries.
Key Details
- Suspect: Drew J. Garnier, 33
- Victims: Samantha Garnier (pregnant wife), two daughters (names withheld)
- Location: Houck Road, Masonville, Delaware County, NY
- Date of Incident: September 4, 2024
- Date of Sentencing: May 15, 2025
- Sentence: 30 years in prison with 15 years post-release supervision
- Charges:
- Originally: Second-degree murder, two counts of attempted murder
- Plea Deal: First-degree manslaughter, two counts of first-degree assault
Reactions or Statements
During sentencing, Samantha’s father made an emotional statement to the court. He alleged that Drew Garnier committed the murder because he “wanted a boy.”
The father has since adopted his grandchildren, stating:
“I am their father now — I will protect them.”
Judge John L. Hubbard expressed deep concern over the tragedy, telling Garnier:
“You took a life and injured your children. They had a right to expect protection from you.”
Delaware County District Attorney Shawn J. Smith praised law enforcement and Safe Against Violence for their work on the case.
“While nothing we do can bring Samantha back, her killer has been put where he belongs,” Smith said.
Investigation or What’s Next
Garnier was arrested at the scene and eventually accepted a plea agreement.
During sentencing, he asked for future contact with his children — a request opposed by the prosecution.
Judge Hubbard issued a no-contact order, but noted it could be revised if the children wish to reconnect in the future.
FAQs
Q: Who was Samantha Garnier?
A: Samantha was a pregnant mother from Masonville, NY, who was killed in a domestic attack by her husband.
Q: What was the motive behind the crime?
A: According to the victim’s father, Garnier was angry because the unborn child was a girl.
Q: What sentence did Drew Garnier receive?
A: He was sentenced to 30 years in prison, followed by 15 years of post-release supervision.
Q: What happened to the surviving children?
A: They were adopted by their maternal grandfather and are receiving care and protection.
Q: Can Garnier contact the children in the future?
A: A no-contact order is in place, but it may be modified by the court if the victims request it.
Summary / Final Takeaway
Drew J. Garnier has been sentenced for a horrific crime that shocked the Masonville community — the fatal stabbing of his pregnant wife and attempted murder of their two children.
Motivated allegedly by gender disappointment, the act has left a family broken and a community mourning. Justice has been served, but the emotional wounds remain.
